Let’s Build Edmonton for the Sunny Days


Montreal, Canada

To state the obvious, Edmonton is a winter city. We often hear the argument that Edmonton shouldn’t invest in walking or biking infrastructure because it gets cold and snowy here sometimes. The most striking Canadian counterpoint to this argument is Montreal.

I was in Montreal recently and I was struck by the fact that they make their public spaces great for the best days of the year. They have beautiful public seating everywhere. They have pedestrian streets and partially enclosed outdoor markets. Montreal is a city that knows it snows or rains or gets cold sometimes, but that organizing your life around those times is a terrible strategy.

The thing is, building our outdoors spaces as though every day of the year was going to be sunny and carefree makes them better all the time. It creates a city that is celebrated by residents whenever the weather is even marginal. That’s what I witnessed in Montreal. The last day I was there it was cool and rainy, but there were thousands of people enjoying the markets and strolling the streets.

This week, Montreal announced that it is going to make a substantial investment in bike infrastructure (Montreal to invest $150M in ambitious new 5-year bike plan). Already, more than 10% of trips in their city centre are on bikes (2.5% for the city as a whole), and their target is 15% for all of Montreal. Our friends at EBC posted these observations about Montreal vs Edmonton weather:

Montreal receives twice the amount of snowfall as Edmonton.

In January, the coldest month of the year, the average daily high in Montreal is -5.4°C. In Edmonton, it’s -6.0°C.

(Although, since 2012, the average high in January in Edmonton has been much warmer, at -3.2°C.)

Even before this latest investment, Montreal has consistently ranked as the most bike-friendly city in North America, and one of the only North American cities to rank in world rankings.

If you’ve ever been stuck on your bike for multiple light cycles in Montreal’s sometimes-congested bike lanes, you’ll know that these kinds of investments pay off by encouraging more people to ride, regardless of the weather.

Many of our public infrastructure decisions in Edmonton have been made as if it’s -30 and snowy here all year round. Let’s make a 180 degree turn. Let’s build patios, beautiful public spaces, great bike lanes, wonderful promenades for strolling. Let’s build for the wonderful days of summer. Then let’s enjoy the great city we’ve built, all year round. We’ll be healthier and happier for it.

A few more pics from that wonderful city in Quebec: (more…)

30 km/h Playground Zones


(image source)

Council has been discussing introducing a 30 km/h into the city’s playground zones. We are strongly in favour of such a move (and eventually a move to 30 km/h for all local roads). Paths for People volunteer Edmond Chui wrote us up this great backgrounder:


With 85% support for lower speed limits for Playground Zones in a city-wide survey, a motion was passed on June 8 for Administration to propose implementation options. There was at least one speaker at the meeting, supporting implementation of Playground Zone as soon as possible (without waiting for blanket default speed limit).

Previous Council/Committee Action

At the June 8, 2017, Community and Public Services Committee meeting, the following motion was passed:

That Administration develop an implementation and funding plan for the installation of
playground zones with reduced speed limits for completion by the end of 2017, which includes the following components:

  1. A definition of playgrounds and parameters of what would be included in this
    program including a process for community input suggesting play areas.
  2. Hours of operation of playground zones.
  3. Operating practice for integration with existing school zones.
  4. Communications plan.
  5. Identification of legislative and enforcement components and accompanying
    plans to address required changes.
  6. Cost estimates for installation and operation including capital production
    costs, enforcement and communications.
  7. Funding options for installation and operations.

Administration’s proposal

On September 7, the report came back to Community & Public Services Committee. Administration proposes:

  • Implementation of Playground Zone by the end of 2017
  • 30 km/h speed limit, from 7:30 AM– 9 PM, all year round including weekends
  • Conversion/extension of all School Zones to Playground Zones
    • the new hours of Playground Zones will apply
    • Calgary tried sunset for Playground Zones, and separate hours for School Zones. They eventually converted all School Zones to Playground Zones with set hours to avoid drivers confusion, and inconsistent summer and winter hours
  • New Playground Zones (standalone, extension from School Zones, etc)
  • All installation and operation costs can be funded within existing budget

Councillors’ response

No decision was made on September 7. Vote is deferred to full council on Sep 12/13 (Tue/Wed).

Bev Esslinger

  • Seems supportive
  • Shared story of witnessing a kid running into traffic

Scott McKeen

Dave Loken

Ben Henderson

Ed Gibbons – Ward 4

Moe Banga – Ward 12


  • Paths for People would like to ensure the position on Playground Zone complements the efforts for the 30 km/h city-wide local roads speed limit push. We would like to see a city-wide local streets speed limit of 30 km/h 24/7; however, 30 km/h Playground Zones is a good step towards that goal.
  • Street/Road design is the ultimate tool in making our streets safer. However, speed limits are a good tool.
  • NATCO shows that at speeds higher than 30 km/h is where people start getting seriously injured and killed.
    • thirtykm
    • 50% of kids get hurt before 9 AM and after 4 PM
    • Healthy and livable cities around the world have kids walking and cycling to schools, soccer fields, and friends’ houses without the fear of getting hurt or dying in traffic. A street with safe speed limits enables mobility freedom for children, and relieves the burden on parents who are compelled to give their kids rides multiple times a day
    • Human make mistakes, especially young children, who are in their development and/or rebellious stages of their lives
    • Kids need 26 judgement skills, and have physical and mental disadvantage
    • “Research has shown that children are a more vulnerable road-user group than adults, as they perceive traffic very differently. According to the Canadian Institute of Child Health, there are approximately 26 judgement skills required to cross a street safely, yet children are challenged in a number of ways. For instance, they
      • have difficulty judging the speed and distance of cars
      • believe if they can see a car, the driver can see them
      • assume a car can stop instantly
      • have a limited peripheral vision
      • have a limited sense of danger.
    • Children are also shorter in stature, and their field of vision is often obstructed by parked cars.”


  • School Zones/Playground Zones may include collector roads, while a 30 km/h city-wide local roads speed limit, depending on implementation, would not
  • Edmonton is the first major Canadian city to adopt Vision Zero
    • Calgary has Playground Zones for years
    • Toronto, Vancouver, and European cities have widespread adoptions of 30 km/h
    • Edmonton is playing catch up, as the 1st “Vision Zero City” (note: embarrassing!)
  • Lower speed limits in Playground Zones received 85% support in a city-wide consultation

Some Media Mentions

Edmonton Journal

CBC News Edmonton

Global News Edmonton

CTV News Edmonton

Metro Edmonton

More Blog Posts Here

Thank you!

Please check your email to confirm you subscription.

Help us spread the word about Paths for People: